Why Generic AI Tools Aren't Enough for HR

July 24, 2025

As HR leaders, you're likely seeing AI tools everywhere—from ChatGPT to Microsoft Copilot to Slack AI. While these tools seem promising, they're not designed for HR's unique challenges. Here's what you need to know before investing in AI for your HR function.

What ChatGPT/MS Co-Pilots Excel At:

  • Summarizing documents and policies
  • Generating basic content (emails, job descriptions)
  • Answering simple policy questions
  • Searching through existing documentation

Where They Fall Short:

  • No System Integration: They can't access your HRIS, payroll, or ticketing systems
  • No Action Capability: They provide information but can't execute tasks
  • Generic Responses: Without employee context, answers are one-size-fits-all
  • No Workflow Automation: Every task still requires manual follow-up

The Hidden Costs of Generic AI in HR

When your team relies on general AI tools, you're actually creating more work:

  1. Increased Ticket Volume: Employees get partial answers and still submit HR tickets
  2. Manual Follow-ups: Every AI interaction requires human verification and action
  3. Compliance Risks: Generic responses may not reflect current policies or employee-specific rules
  4. Fragmented Experience: Employees bounce between multiple tools to complete simple requests

Action Steps for HR Leaders

Before Choosing Any AI Tool, Ask:

  1. "Can it take action, or just provide information?"
    • Look for solutions that can execute workflows end-to-end
  2. "Does it integrate with our existing HR systems?"
    • Ensure the AI can read from and write to your core HR platforms
  3. "Can it provide personalized, role-specific responses?"
    • Generic answers frustrate employees and create compliance risks
  4. "Will it reduce or increase our ticket volume?"
    • The right AI should resolve issues before they become tickets

The Bottom Line

Generic AI tools like ChatGPT and Copilot serve as useful assistants, but they're not HR solutions. For meaningful impact, you need AI that's purpose-built for HR—one that integrates with your systems, understands your people, and actually gets work done.